Software engineering: Should it be a product, or a craft? (gokhan.sari.me)

In a recent commentary, an experienced software engineer critiques the prevailing mindset in the industry that prioritizes product commercialization over craftsmanship. While recognizing the utility of AI and tools like LLMs in enhancing workflows, the author argues that the trend towards "vibe coding" diminishes the quality, reliability, and maintainability of software. The distinction made between "product" and "craft" highlights the risk of prioritizing marketability over sound design principles, leading to subpar solutions that merely meet immediate commercial demands. The significance of this discussion for the AI/ML community lies in the ongoing balance between leveraging artificial intelligence for efficiency and preserving the foundational principles of software development craftsmanship. The author emphasizes that true value comes from deeply understanding the technology and nurturing a culture that values thoughtful design. As AI continues to evolve, this commentary urges developers and companies to prioritize craftsmanship to ensure that their innovations not only fulfill their intended functions but also offer enduring aesthetic and functional quality.