Why papers get desk-rejected before peer review even starts (presub.app)

🤖 AI Summary
Recent developments in peer review practices highlight the increasing impact of anonymity policies on paper submissions in the AI/ML community. For instance, at ICML 2026, 497 papers were desk-rejected due to violations of large language model (LLM) usage rules, while NeurIPS 2026 rejected 178 papers for not being sufficiently human-written. Particularly alarming, at CHI 2027, 20.9% of desk-rejected papers were due to violations of double-blind anonymity, often unnoticed as they were embedded in document metadata, image properties, or supplementary files. This raises awareness about the importance of thorough checks to ensure compliance with venue guidelines. Understanding and addressing these anonymity issues is crucial for authors, as violations can lead to significant setbacks in the academic publishing process. Submissions must not only obscure authorship in the visible text but also eliminate identifying metadata found in file properties and supplementary materials. The shift towards stricter policies reflects a broader concern within the AI/ML research community about maintaining integrity in anonymous peer review, making it essential for researchers to adopt meticulous practices when preparing their manuscripts. Failure to adhere to these guidelines can result in desk rejection, ultimately influencing an author's visibility and contributions to the field.
Loading comments...
loading comments...