Grammarly Is Offering ‘Expert’ AI Reviews From Your Favorite Authors—Dead or Alive (www.wired.com)

Grammarly has unveiled a new feature called "Expert Review," allowing users to solicit feedback on their writing from virtual personas of renowned authors and academics, both living and deceased. While the tool harnesses generative AI to simulate critiques, it raises significant ethical questions, particularly regarding copyright and the legitimacy of attributing opinions to figures who did not consent to be represented. Despite a disclaimer clarifying that these suggestions do not imply endorsement, critics argue that without the involvement of the actual experts, these reviews undermine genuine scholarship. This feature highlights the AI/ML community's ongoing debates about the ethical implications of using AI-generated content and the potential risks of appropriating the intellectual contributions of established thinkers. The technology aims to enhance user experience by providing tailored suggestions based on the styles and insights of significant figures. However, the controversy surrounding its implementation reflects a broader concern within academia about the erosion of human expertise and the risks of AI reducing individual scholars to mere resources, thus complicating the role of educators and professional writing.